After trekking nearly 400 kilometres over 12 days, a group of villagers from Arunachal Pradesh’s Siang valley arrived in Itanagar carrying a clear message for the government: consult the people before making decisions that could reshape their land, livelihoods and future.
The 15 marchers, representing villages that could be affected by the proposed 11,000-MW Siang Upper Multipurpose Project (SUMP), began their journey from Geku in Upper Siang district under the banner of the Adi Galo Welfare Society (AGWS). Their foot march was aimed at highlighting growing local opposition to the proposed mega hydropower project and pressing for direct dialogue between the government and affected communities.
According to AGWS, repeated appeals to the government have failed to generate a meaningful response. The organisation said it had earlier submitted a memorandum to Chief Minister Pema Khandu detailing its concerns over the project, but received no official reply, prompting villagers to undertake the arduous journey to the state capital.
Upon reaching Itanagar, the protesters reiterated a series of demands, including the release of individuals arrested during anti-dam protests, withdrawal of security forces deployed in the Siang belt, and revocation of suspension orders issued against gaon buras and government employees allegedly linked to the agitation. They also demanded direct consultations with communities likely to face displacement or other impacts if the project proceeds.
AGWS president Gei Bagra expressed disappointment over what he described as the government’s reluctance to engage with affected residents despite repeated requests. He said the organisation would wait two days for a response before deciding on its next course of action.
The protest march comes against the backdrop of prolonged unrest in the Siang valley, where opposition to preliminary survey activities has led to demonstrations, shutdowns and clashes between protesters and security personnel.
In a move seen as an attempt to ease tensions, the government on November 7 released four anti-dam activists who had been detained under the Arunachal Pradesh Unlawful Activities (Prevention) Act since October 9. However, opposition groups continue to demand the release of all remaining detainees, withdrawal of criminal cases and removal of security forces from the region.
At the heart of the conflict is the proposed Siang Upper Multipurpose Project, which is expected to generate around 11,200 MW of electricity if implemented. While the government has projected the project as strategically important, local communities fear it could lead to large-scale displacement, submergence of ancestral lands, environmental degradation and irreversible impacts on indigenous culture and identity.
The concerns are rooted in the broader history of large dam projects in South Asia. After Independence, India placed major emphasis on hydropower development as a tool for economic growth. Then Prime Minister Jawaharlal Nehru famously described large dams as the “temples of modern India”, and institutions such as the National Hydroelectric Power Corporation (NHPC) were established to expand the sector.
For decades, major dam projects were viewed as symbols of development and nation-building. However, attitudes gradually changed as communities witnessed the social and environmental costs associated with projects such as the Sardar Sarovar, Tehri and Hirakud dams. Similar concerns have been raised in the case of Bangladesh’s Kaptai Dam, which displaced thousands of indigenous people and permanently submerged vast stretches of land.
Against this backdrop, many residents of the Siang valley remain unconvinced by official assurances that no final decision has been taken. Chief Minister Pema Khandu has repeatedly stated that neither the state government nor the Centre has approved construction of the dam and that only a pre-feasibility report is currently under consideration. He has also assured that no project will proceed without extensive consultations and public consent.
Yet many villagers question the rationale behind conducting the pre-feasibility study itself. Their concern is that once surveys are completed, technical reports prepared and substantial public funds invested in the planning process, pressure to proceed with construction may become inevitable, regardless of local opposition or environmental concerns.
Adding to the debate are questions about whether the proposed project can realistically serve as India’s response to China’s planned hydropower development on the Yarlung Tsangpo. While the government has cited China’s upstream activities as a strategic factor in evaluating the project’s feasibility, critics argue that the potential risks to downstream communities remain poorly understood.
Environmental groups and researchers have also warned that rapid hydropower development across the Yarlung Tsangpo-Siang basin could expose communities to complex ecological and disaster-related risks. Critics argue that issues such as transparency, public participation and long-term environmental safeguards must be addressed before any decision on the project is taken.
For now, the arrival of the villagers in Itanagar has once again brought the central question of the Siang dam debate into sharp focus: can a project of such scale move forward without first earning the trust and consent of the people who stand to be most affected by it?
